PbPA: Is Evey Grumpy?

Which do you predict will have the higher total?


  • Total voters
    14
Best Character

Zules

☕☕☕☕
Admin
Likes received
4,943
Umbration

Caprice
PbPA = Page by Page Analysis
You may make other threads similar to this if you wish!

Let's do a page by page analysis to find the ratio of grumpy to non-grumpy Eveys in the comic. This is really important science.

Please go 1 page at a time (just one page per post, no double posting, so that nobody takes over the thread and corrupts our analysis with overreaching personal bias) and analyze the number of grumpy Eveys on that page. Of course, "Is this Evey grumpy?" is a subjective question, so we may have to make some judgement calls that are based on individual opinion. Also, some pages will not contain Evey at all, so the data will be zero and zero. You may skip Eveyless pages and go straight to the next page with an Evey.


I'll begin.

Page 1:
0 grumpy Eveys
1 non-grumpy Evey

TOTAL:
0 grumpy Eveys
1 non-grumpy Evey
 
Last edited:

Avidro

Hiatus Master
Admin
Likes received
2,632
Umbration

Corporeality
Page 2:
0 grumpy Eveys
4 non-grumpy Eveys

TOTAL:
0 grumpy Eveys
5 non-grumpy Eveys

Prologue is pretty stingy with the grumps.
 

Zules

☕☕☕☕
Admin
Likes received
4,943
Umbration

Caprice
There are 2 Eveys on this next page, but one has his face completely hidden. I will have to use reasoning based on body language and context to assume he is Non-Grumpy.

Page 3:
0 grumpy Eveys
2 non-grumpy Eveys

TOTAL:
0 grumpy Eveys
7 non-grumpy Eveys
 

Val

Random Pegasus
Super Patron
Likes received
1,685
Umbration

Cosmos
Following the same reasoning with the 2 hidden Eveys on this page, we can safely assume he's non-grumpy.
He didn't really have any reason to be grumpy in the prologue.

Page 4:
0 grumpy Eveys
6 non-grumpy Eveys

Total:
0 grumpy eveys
13 non-grumpy Eveys
 

Smiley100P

The only Ace Attorney you need
Likes received
504
Umbration

Innervation
Page 5:
0 grumpy eveys
4 non-grumpy eveys

Total:
0 grumpy eveys
17 non-grumpy eveys


Theyll catch up
 

Val

Random Pegasus
Super Patron
Likes received
1,685
Umbration

Cosmos
Soon

Page 6:
0 grumpy Eveys
3 non-grumpy Eveys

Total:
0 grumpy Eveys
20 non-grumpy Eveys
 

Syril Dawntreader

Thane of Fife
Likes received
227
Umbration

Innervation
Dzuna is a pretty good reason to be grumpy.

Page 7:
2 grumpy Eveys
1 non-grumpy Evey

Total:
2 grumpy Eveys
21 non-grumpy Eveys
 

Val

Random Pegasus
Super Patron
Likes received
1,685
Umbration

Cosmos
Assuming Evey#3 is still grumpy, while Evey#4 is just shocked.
So that makes

Page 8:
3 grumpy Eveys
2 non-grumpy Eveys

Total:
5 grumpy Eveys
23 non-grumpy Eveys
 

Zules

☕☕☕☕
Admin
Likes received
4,943
Umbration

Caprice
Time for a small Evey drought.

For Eveyless pages, we can--for fun--ask ourselves the question, "If Evey were here, would he be grumpy?" For this page, I'll answer, "no!"

Page 9:
0 grumpy Eveys
0 non-grumpy Eveys

Total:
5 grumpy Eveys
23 non-grumpy Eveys
 

Jimothy

Rogue Chemist, Supreme Summoner
Likes received
1,706
Umbration

Radiance
... maybe he'd be a little grumpy.

Page 10:
0 grumpy Eveys
0 non-grumpy Eveys

Total:
5 grumpy Eveys
23 non-grumpy Eveys
 

Val

Random Pegasus
Super Patron
Likes received
1,685
Umbration

Cosmos
Nah, I think he would have been excited about the treasure thing

Page 11:
0 grumpy Eveys
0 non-grumpy Eveys

Total:
5 grumpy Eveys
23 non-grumpy Eveys
 

Avidro

Hiatus Master
Admin
Likes received
2,632
Umbration

Corporeality
"If I find another hornworm, I'm going to lose. my. mind!!!"

Page 12:
1 grumpy Evey
0 non-grumpy Eveys

Total:
6 grumpy Eveys
23 non-grumpy Eveys
 

Zules

☕☕☕☕
Admin
Likes received
4,943
Umbration

Caprice
Evey would definitely probably be grumpy that his dad is flailing around a shovel with a bad back.

Page 13:
0 grumpy Eveys
0 non-grumpy Eveys

Total:
6 grumpy Eveys
23 non-grumpy Eveys
 

Avidro

Hiatus Master
Admin
Likes received
2,632
Umbration

Corporeality
Does an extremely grumpy Goglio count for maybe half a grumpy Evey?

Page 14:
0 grumpy Eveys
0 non-grumpy Eveys

Total:
6 grumpy Eveys
23 non-grumpy Eveys
 

Zules

☕☕☕☕
Admin
Likes received
4,943
Umbration

Caprice
Page 15:
0 grumpy Eveys
0 non-grumpy Eveys

For Eveyless pages, we can--for fun--ask ourselves the question, "If Evey were here, would he be grumpy?" For this page, I'll answer, "no!"
He probably wouldn't be grumpy, just startled or protective of his dad!

Total:
6 grumpy Eveys
23 non-grumpy Eveys
 

EstherTb

Best FireBender
Likes received
3,701
Umbration

Duality
Page 16:
0 grumpy Eveys
0 non-grumpy Eveys

Not grumpy yet! Only a slight headache with a couple side-affects

Total:
6 grumpy Eveys
23 non-grumpy Eveys
 

Zules

☕☕☕☕
Admin
Likes received
4,943
Umbration

Caprice
Rule Amendment: In the case of a stretch of pages with no Evey, you may skip to the next page with an Evey.

Skipping to...
Page 19:
4 grumpy Eveys
0 non-grumpy Eveys

Total:
10 grumpy Eveys
23 non-grumpy Eveys

A good grumpy boost!
 

Val

Random Pegasus
Super Patron
Likes received
1,685
Umbration

Cosmos
Page 20:
1 grumpy Evey
1 non-grumpy Evey

Total:
11 grumpy Eveys
24 non-grumpy Eveys
 

EstherTb

Best FireBender
Likes received
3,701
Umbration

Duality
Page 21:
0 grumpy Evey
3 non-grumpy Evey

11 grumpy Eveys
27 Non-grumpy Eveys
 

TheJLT

Oegyen's 3rd Friend
Likes received
1,943
Umbration

Cognizance
How do you declare best character?
 
Top